Overview
A monograph of nine chapters, seven figures and seventeen tables resting on 360 sources: four centuries of coffee and cacao history, Fiji's official kava trade returns for 2013–2025, Vanuatu's trade figures, world coffee and cocoa series, three rounds of US retail kava testing and a 2024 national panel of kava users. All three drinks passed through the same seven stages, but kava moved from its first public house abroad to its first farms abroad in 13 years, against about 140 for coffee. The older crops show an origin can lose share and still sell far more; kava's current boom is demand-led, with Fiji's exports up from 137 to 1,015.7 tonnes between 2013 and 2025. Whether Pacific growers share in it depends on testing every export lot, honest origin names and a fair blind tasting.
Abstract
Key Findings
- Three drinks, one path. Coffee, chocolate and kava each passed through ritual use, outsider aversion, entry as medicine, a public house, new ground, tiering by lineage and origin, and blind judgment, though never in a fixed order.
- Kava moved fastest. From first public house abroad to first plantations abroad took about 140 years for coffee, 130 for chocolate and 13 for kava (Boca Raton, 2002, to California, 2015).
- The Pacific built the paying kava house first. Suva's kava saloons were trading by 1923, Pohnpei's first sakau bar opened in 1972 and Port Vila's urban nakamals spread from the late 1970s; the 2002 Boca Raton bar adapted that commercial tradition, not the ceremony.
- An origin can lose share and still win. Ethiopia's coffee output is about 6.8 times its 1960 level, with record exports of US$3 billion in 2025/26; Latin America's cacao output rose fifteenfold as its share fell from 63% to 12%. Yemen, Haiti and Mexico were passed by.
- Kava's boom is led by demand. Fiji's exports rose from 137 tonnes in 2013 to 1,015.7 tonnes (FJD 79.1 million) in 2025, Vanuatu's export price from VT 1,108 to VT 5,086 a kilogram, and the Luganville green price doubled in 2025.
- Receipts are not growers' income. Fiji's 2025 imports equaled 81% of its export weight, and its farm-gate price fell from FJD 95 to FJD 63.75 a kilogram between 2019 and 2023.
- Microbial quality is the weak point. Retail microbial pass rates were 49%, 73% and 68% across three survey rounds, while every product met heavy-metal limits and the two newer rounds found no mycotoxins or screened pesticides.
- Protect the places, judge the cup. The authors propose registered origin names that leave the word kava free, lot testing at export, an open provenance register, and a blind Pacific-versus-mainland tasting with separate noble and Isa-type divisions.
The short version
The question
Coffee and chocolate became everyday drinks around the world only after growers planted them far from where they began. Kava is now being planted on the US mainland. Does the history of the two older crops tell Pacific growers whether new farms will bring them more buyers, or take buyers away?
Why it matters
American kava has grown from a single bar in 2002 to about five hundred, and some of those bars now pour root from mainland farms. A bigger trade does not automatically mean a better living for the families who grow kava in Vanuatu, Fiji and the rest of the Pacific; the coffee and cacao records include origins that thrived inside a larger market and origins that faded.
What it draws on
A monograph of nine chapters resting on 360 sources: four centuries of coffee and cacao history, official trade returns for Fiji (2013–2025) and Vanuatu, world coffee and cocoa series from the USDA, ICO and ICCO, three rounds of US retail kava testing covering 40 or 41 products each, a 2024 national panel of 1,000 past-year kava users, and thirteen laboratory assays of Solomon Islands kava. It carries seven figures and seventeen tables, ten of them statistical appendices.
Where, when and who
Written by Tyler Blythe, an ethnobotanist who has grown kava in California and Florida since 2015; Douglas LaRose, a cacao grower in Ghana and executive director of the Kava Coalition; and Jeffrey Bowman, who opened the first kava bar on the US mainland in Boca Raton in 2002. The record runs to late 2026 and the outlook to 2035. Published in The Journal of American Kava, Volume 2, Article 028.
What it argues
All three drinks passed through the same seven stages, from ritual to blind tasting, but kava has moved fastest: thirteen years separated its first public house abroad from its first farms abroad, against about 140 for coffee and 130 for chocolate. In the older crops, origins such as Ethiopia and Ecuador sold far more even as their share shrank, while Yemen, Haiti and Mexico did not. Kava's present boom is driven by demand: Fiji shipped 137 tonnes in 2013 and 1,015.7 in 2025, and Vanuatu's green price doubled in 2025.
What it means for the trade
The authors' first remedy is lot testing at export, with results going back to the people who dried the root, because microbial quality, not chemistry, is where kava still fails most often. After that come honest origin names backed by registered protections, an open register of where cultivars came from, and a fair blind tasting of Pacific and mainland kava.
What it means for kava drinkers
In the newest US retail testing, kava products were free of heavy-metal, pesticide and mycotoxin problems, but about one product in three still failed microbial limits. Drinkers can ask where their kava was grown, prefer brands that publish lot tests, and keep kratom well away from the bowl, since a regulator who meets the two together may treat them alike.
What comes next
Mainland production figures have not been published, Fiji has no farm-gate price series for the boom years, and no blind tasting of Pacific against mainland kava has been held. The authors set out the indicators that will show whether mainland kava complements island supply or replaces it, propose a tested, graded Pacific kava exchange for a companion paper, and call for a controlled comparison of the same cultivars grown in both regions.
Version of record
The full monograph — nine chapters, seven figures, seventeen tables and 360 references — is published in The Journal of American Kava. The accepted manuscript and the Solomon Islands laboratory certificates are on Zenodo.
Discussion
The Association's fuller account of the monograph for growers, bars and the trade: what it compares, what the numbers show, and what the authors propose.
What the argument rests on — The comparison draws on primary historical accounts from Mecca in 1511 to the Hawaiian ʻawa growers of 1874, crop genetics, and current statistics: Fiji Bureau of Statistics returns for kava exports and imports from 2013 to 2025, Vanuatu's quarterly trade figures, the USDA's coffee tables, the International Cocoa Organization's annual series, and three Kava Coalition retail surveys tested at an ISO/IEC 17025-accredited laboratory. Laboratory figures for Kali ISA come from the companion article in this journal (Art. 026); the thirteen Solomon Islands assays are reproduced in Supplementary File S2. Where the authors draw on their own experience as growers, importers and bar operators, the article says so.
Three drinks, one path
The monograph lines kava up against coffee and chocolate step by step. All three began as sacred drinks shared from one vessel in a set order. Outsiders recoiled at first: a market inspector shut down coffee drinkers in Mecca, a Milanese merchant called chocolate fit for pigs, and Georg Forster described kava preparation with open disgust. Each then crossed into foreign markets as a medicine before it was sold for pleasure, and each acquired a public house of its own. The authors sort this into seven recurring stages. They are careful to say these are a way of organizing the record, not a law: the stages overlap, and no crop runs through them one, two, three in sequence.
| Stage | Coffee | Chocolate | Kava |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ritual use | Yemeni Sufi devotions, 15th c.; Ethiopian buna | Upper Amazon, c. 5,300 years ago; Chiapas residues, 1800–1400 BCE | Lapita settlement, c. 3,000 years ago; European record from 1616 |
| Outsider aversion | Mecca, 1511 | Benzoni, 1565 | Forster, 1777; missionary campaigns |
| Entry as medicine | Aden, c. 1470; London, 1652 | Hernández, 1570 | US dispensatory, 1898; extract bans, 2002 |
| The public house | Istanbul, 1555; London, 1652 | White's, London, 1693 | Suva by 1923; Pohnpei, 1972; Port Vila, late 1970s; Boca Raton, 2002 |
| New ground | Java, 1696; Brazil, 1727 | São Tomé, 1824; Ghana, c. 1879 | Hawaiʻi, mid-1980s; California, 2015 |
| Tiering by lineage and origin | Arabica and robusta; Kona, Blue Mountain | Criollo and forastero; fine-flavor grades | Vanuatu Kava Act, 2002 (in force 2008); Codex standard, 2020 |
| Blind judgment | Best of Panama, 2004 | International Chocolate Awards, 2019 | Not yet held |
Condensed from the stage matrix in the introduction of the journal article, which marks each entry as direct evidence or the authors' interpretation.
The most striking result is speed. On the article's own dates, coffee took about 140 years to go from its first public house abroad to its first plantations abroad, and chocolate about 130. Kava did it in 13, from the Boca Raton bar in 2002 to the first California plantings in 2015.
The names and the lineages
The first two chapters look at what each drink is called and how each crop divides. Coffee's Arabic name, qahwa, was first a poetic word for wine. Cacao carries the oldest datable name of the three, reconstructed in the languages of Mexico's Gulf Coast to about 1000 BC. Kava descends from a Proto-Polynesian word for both the plant and a sharp or bitter taste, though the authors caution that “bitter” in the old Polynesian sense did not mean what it means to an English speaker.
Each crop also splits into a lineage prized for flavor and one valued for strength or hardiness: arabica and robusta, criollo and forastero, and in kava the noble cultivars and the heavier ones. The biology differs in every case (two species in coffee, two crossable populations in cacao, sterile clones in kava), but the market habit is the same, ranking one group for flavor and discounting the other. The hardy lineage did much of the work on new ground: forastero carried cacao across West Africa, and robusta built Vietnam's coffee industry.
For kava, the article argues that Papuan Isa-type kava belongs to neither half of Vanuatu's noble-versus-two-day split. Genetic surveys place Isa and Iwi outside both clusters. Kali ISA, the mainland line selected from Isa, carried flavokavains at 1.7–3.6% of kavalactones across seven assays, far below two-day roots, and the article reads its place alongside noble kava as similar to the place fine robusta now holds beside specialty arabica. It is equally clear about the limits: Kali ISA does not qualify as noble under either the Codex list or the Harmonized standard, passing the flavokavain limits proves neither nobility nor safety, and the international standards do not admit Isa-type kava to trade as a beverage. Those standards are the ones the authors' case has to be made against.
The same chapter adds a pointed comparison. Of thirteen commercial Solomon Islands assays of three cultivars listed as noble, run by the laboratory that tested Kali ISA, ten exceeded the 0.4% absolute flavokavain limit and nine exceeded the 5% ratio limit. The point is not that one origin is worse than another, but that the same limits bind every origin that blends root or lists cultivars of mixed descent.
Rites, medicine and the long road to acceptance
Chapters 3 to 5 compare how the three drinks were made, served and resisted. The ceremonies share a small set of acts: breaking the seed or root, raising a foam by pouring from a height, serving one cup at a time in a fixed order, setting a portion aside for gods or ancestors, and disposing of what is left in a prescribed way. Kava is the only one of the three whose ceremonies still keep both grammars of service, the cup that maps rank in Tonga and Samoa and the cup that dissolves it in the Vanuatu nakamal.
All three entered foreign societies labelled as medicine, and the label did commercial work, giving a strange and bitter drink a reason to be tried. Kava's medical career ran from the 1898 dispensatory to the European extract bans of 2002, which cut Fiji's and Vanuatu's exports by about three-quarters in a single quarter. Coffee won acceptance by sheer weight of drinkers, chocolate by being sweetened until it no longer tasted foreign, and kava, the authors argue, is taking a third route in the kava bar, where it is mostly served as it is, root and water from a common bowl.
The older crops met regulators only after they were accepted: Sweden's coffee bans, adulteration cases under the 1906 US food law, and the EU's cadmium limits on chocolate. Kava is entering that phase now, and for a dried root the first question is microbial. The Kava Coalition's three retail rounds found every product within heavy-metal limits and, in the two newer rounds, no aflatoxins, ochratoxin A or screened pesticides. Microbial pass rates were 49%, 73% and 68%, and only the first improvement is statistically distinguishable from chance.
The public house
Chapter 6 sets the London coffeehouse, the London chocolate house, the Port Vila nakamal and the American kava bar side by side. Within about two generations each was part of everyday city life. The coffeehouse was a tavern without wine; the kava bar, on the authors' reading, is a tavern without alcohol, a late-night room for people who want company without drinking.
The American kava bar did not copy a village ceremony. The Pacific had already built a paying trade in kava by the cup: Suva's kava saloons were operating by 1923, Pohnpei's first sakau bar opened in 1972, and Port Vila's urban nakamals spread from the late 1970s. The Boca Raton bar of 2002 adapted that commercial tradition. The article also notes a social change: the London coffeehouse and the chocolate house were men's rooms, and the urban nakamal grew from the men's house, while US kava drinkers today divide almost evenly between men and women.
| House | Opened | Early count | Latest count |
|---|---|---|---|
| London coffeehouse | 1652 | Several hundred, c. 1700 | 551 (1739) |
| London chocolate house | 1690s, as a distinct type | A handful | One, as a private club |
| Port Vila nakamal | Late 1970s | More than 60 (1991) | About 250 today |
| American kava bar | 2002 | 178 (2019) | About 500 (2025); 670 public listings (2026) |
From the house comparison in Chapter 6 of the journal article. The 2026 listing count is not on the same basis as the earlier bar counts.
New ground: what Brazil and Ghana show
Chapter 7 is the core of the forward argument. Coffee broke Yemen's monopoly through Dutch Java, then French Saint-Domingue, then Brazil, which became the largest producer by the 1840s and still grows about 35% of the world's coffee. Cacao reached Ghana around 1879 and Ghana was the world's largest exporter by 1911; Africa now grows 69% of the crop. In both cases the new ground soon outgrew the old, and the market grew many times over.
The authors set the mainland kava plantings in that line. Between 2013 and 2019 Tyler Blythe acquired Isa, Hiwa and twenty other cultivars from growers in Hawaiʻi, began planting in California in 2015, and selected for survival through mainland winters and summers. Isa reached Hawaiʻi in the mid-1980s, before the biodiversity treaties existed, Hiwa descends from Polynesian settlement, and both were acquired within the United States, so no treaty restricts them; the article adds that standing outside a treaty does not end the obligation, and proposes three reciprocal commitments: an open register recording where Pacific and mainland plantings came from, field trials run jointly in both regions, and sharing of clean planting stock, propagation methods and dieback research.
On the origin side, the pressures are disease, labor and time. Fiji's agriculture minister put the share of farmers affected by dieback at about one in five in January 2026. Seasonal work schemes in Australia and New Zealand, schooling in town and permanent migration all draw working-age people away from village gardens, and kava, propagated from cuttings and dug by hand after three years or more, needs them more than most crops.
| Measure | Then | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Fiji kava exports | 137 t, FJD 6.6m (2013) | 1,015.7 t, FJD 79.1m (2025) |
| Fiji kava imports | 328 t (2013) | 824.9 t (2025), 529.1 t of it from Papua New Guinea |
| Fiji farm-gate price | FJD 95/kg (2019) | FJD 63.75/kg (2023); no series yet for 2024–25 |
| Vanuatu kava exports | VT 766m a year (2011–14) | VT 5.35bn (2024), 68% of domestic exports |
| Vanuatu green price, Luganville | VT 500/kg (Jan 2025) | VT 1,000/kg (Aug 2025) |
| US kava bars | 1 (2002) | About 500 (2025) |
From Appendix Tables A3 and A5 of the journal article. Fiji's figures are gross receipts and include root imported, repacked and re-exported.
Where the market stands
The authors read kava's present as a boom led by demand, not a supply failure. High prices alongside rising volumes are the signature: Fiji's exports grew about sevenfold by volume between 2013 and 2025, Vanuatu's export price rose from VT 1,108 a kilogram in 2017 to VT 5,086 at the end of 2025, and the United States took more than half of Fiji's 2024 exports by value. Vanuatu's exports have barely moved over twenty-five years, not because it grows less but because its own nakamals drink the increase. On the mainland, production has not been disclosed; the authors' own plantings supply their bars and a few others, and they expect significant harvests by 2035.
Two figures in this chapter deserve care, and the article gives it. First, gross export receipts are not growers' income: in 2025 Fiji imported root equal to 81% of its export weight, so Fijian-grown root made up anywhere from a fifth to all of what left the country, and Fiji's farm-gate price fell from FJD 95 to 63.75 a kilogram between 2019 and 2023 while export receipts held steady. Second, the 2024 national survey's figure of about one adult in nine is a screening rate in an opt-in panel; the authors treat their extrapolation to 28.6 million adults as an upper bound, not a prevalence.
Names on the cup
Coffee and cacao origins kept their premiums by turning place-names into enforceable rights, but mostly after the bulk trade had already moved elsewhere. Kona's growers proved their case with a simple balance, more than 20 million pounds sold as Kona each year from a belt harvesting about 2.7 million, and recovered more than US$33 million. The article sees the same structural risk in the Pacific today: imported Papuan and ni-Vanuatu root can leave a Fijian port as Fijian, because an overseas buyer sees where the sack was shipped, not where the root grew. Fiji's 2026 Yaqona Bill and its new chemotype testing of every imported consignment are steps in that direction, and the article argues that registered geographical indications for Vanuatu Kava, Fiji Yaqona and the other Pacific names would carry the protection into every market that recognizes them.
What a geographical indication cannot do, the authors argue, is claim the word kava itself, any more than any country owns the word coffee. Their proposed settlement protects the place-names, leaves the species name as the Codex standard defines it, and requires every product to state where it was grown. That rule protects Pacific sellers from mainland or blended kava sold under their names, and American growers from imported kava sold as American-grown. The Association's own “American Grown” certification mark works the same way, certifying where the kava was grown and leaving the word kava free.
The judgment ahead
Every crop that moved to new ground eventually faced a blind test of reputation: Napa wines in Paris in 1976, a Panamanian Geisha in 2004, and a Taiwanese chocolate maker's origin bar in 2019. Kava has not had its equivalent. The article proposes two experiments with different jobs. A commercial judgment would score Pacific and mainland kava as sold, blind, at one serving concentration, using the sensory vocabulary of the companion Organoleptic Spectrum monograph. A controlled origin trial would hold processing constant, matching root fractions, drying, milling and extraction, so that any difference in the cup could be put down to where the kava grew. Neither side should run it: the authors suggest a facilitating body that takes no part in judging, independent panelists from both sides of the Pacific, separate divisions for noble and Isa-type roots, and publication of the protocol and raw scores.
Will new ground help or hurt the Pacific?
Chapter 9 turns history into a forecast. The older crops show an origin can lose share and still win. Ethiopia's coffee output is nearly seven times what it was in 1960, earning a record US$3 billion in 2025/26; Latin America's share of world cacao fell from 63% in 1900 to 12% in 2010, yet its output rose fifteenfold. Yemen, Haiti and Mexico, by contrast, were passed by. Across those five cases the authors find three conditions that fit: research-backed, high-yielding planting material, a price that actually reaches growers, and the ability to recover from war, revolution and blight. They are explicit that five cases support these only as hypotheses.
The article then lists eight risks for the decade ahead, each with a precedent from coffee or cacao and a proposed remedy:
- Quality at export. The largest risk, in the authors' judgment. Two Fijian processors are on the FDA's Salmonella import alert, and a HACCP certificate does not show that a given shipment is clean. Remedy: test a representative sample of every export lot, send the results back to growers and processors, and hold failing lots.
- Harvest lag. Island and mainland growers who planted on the strength of 2025–26 prices will all be harvesting around 2028–2031, the mechanism behind coffee's glut in the 1890s.
- Weather. Cyclone Pam cut Vanuatu's kava exports by three-quarters in 2015; a crop grown in several climates is less exposed.
- Concentration and disease. Kava has only about thirty distinct genotypes among 103 accessions. The authors propose a quarantined duplicate collection in a second climate that deposits with and draws from the Pacific Community's genebank in Suva, not a rival to it.
- Value captured downstream. Coffee and cocoa farmers keep about a tenth of retail value; as kava moves into cans and powders, the origin needs to own some of that processing.
- Regulation. The water-prepared beverage is generally treated as a conventional food in the US, but the FDA has found no basis to treat kava as generally recognized as safe as an ingredient in other foods, and nearly a third of 2025 US poison-center reports involving kava also involved kratom. Keeping kratom apart from the bowl is part of protecting kava's standing.
- Traceability. The EU's deforestation rules do not cover kava, but Pohnpei's sakau boom cleared most of the island's intact forest in twenty years, and buyers will ask the question.
- Land. Customary tenure keeps island supply in many family hands and slows its response to price; mainland supply adds root without any island family parting with its land.
What the next studies need to settle
- Complement or substitution? The authors expect mainland kava to complement Pacific supply through 2035 where it fills gaps between harvests and recruits new drinkers. The test is in the numbers to watch: repeat US orders for Pacific root, volumes sold under verifiable origin names, and the prices island growers actually receive.
- Mainland cost and volume. No mainland planted area, harvest or production cost has been published, the authors' included, so the relative price of the two supplies cannot yet be weighed.
- Grower prices in the boom. Fiji's farm-gate series stops at 2023. Until it covers 2024 and 2025, the evidence that higher prices reached island farms is Vanuatu's alone.
- Origin fingerprinting. Kavalactone profiles separate cultivar groups but cannot prove which island or state grew a root. Elemental and isotopic reference data, as used for Kona coffee, would.
- Same cultivar, two places. The authors' experience is that Pacific clones shift in maturation and root balance in Florida and California; a controlled common-garden trial has yet to measure it.
- A graded exchange. A companion economic paper is to test whether a Pacific-hosted spot exchange, with every lot tested and keeping its cultivar and island of origin, could pay its way at kava's current scale.
Disclosures and conflicts of interest
All three authors earn a living from kava and are affiliated with the American Kava Association, publisher of this page and of The Journal of American Kava. Tyler Blythe co-founded Root of Happiness and owns Kali Kava, which selected the Kali ISA and Kali Hiwa lines, so the article's treatment of Isa-type kava, mainland cultivation and the Kali names bears directly on his interests; the lines carry no patent or plant variety protection, granted or applied for. He is also a partner in the testing business KavaLytics, and testing is the article's first remedy. Douglas LaRose is executive director of the Kava Coalition, whose market surveys and standards the article cites. Jeffrey Bowman owns Nakava LLC and The Nak, which serves American-grown kava; Bowman and Blythe own American Kava Farms. The Coalition's H1 2026 survey tested products from Root of Happiness and Nakamal at Home among others. Trademark and certification-mark applications held by companies of the authors and by the Association are listed in the article's conflicts statement.
Tyler Blythe is Editor-in-Chief of the journal and Jeffrey Bowman an editor; neither took part in handling this manuscript. It was handled by Travis Lowin, an editor who is not an author and who is Blythe's business partner at Root of Happiness, and was accepted after the authors revised version 1.0 in response to Computational Manuscript Review. No new experiments were run for the article; its laboratory figures come from the companion Kali ISA article and from Supplementary File S2. The authors used an AI assistant to verify figures, calculate derived values and redraw the charts, and reviewed every change themselves.
References
Cite This
Blythe, T.; LaRose, D.; Bowman, J. Kava, Coffee and Chocolate: The Public Life of Three Drinks and the Future of a Pacific Crop. J. Am. Kava 2026, 2, 028. https://journalofamericankava.org/articles/kava-coffee-chocolate